QTnurnr~iu m4rnlngiral ilnutqly Continuing LEHRE UND VVEHRE MAGAZIN FUER Ev.-LuTH. HOMILETIK THEOLOGICAL QUARTERLY-THEOLOGICAL MONTHLY Vol. VII January, 1936 No.1 CONTENTS Page Testifying the Gospel of the Grace of God. Th. Engelder. • • • 1 Der Pietismus. Theo. Hoyer . • . . • . . . . . . . . . • . . . • . . • . • • • • • 6 Present-Day Problems of Lutheranism. F. Kreiss. . • • • . • • • • 14 Luther on the Study and Use of the Ancient Languages. F. v. N. Painter . . . . . . • . .• 23 Der Schriftgrund fuer die Lehre von del' satisfactio vicaria. P. E. Kretzrnann . . • • . • . • •• 27 Sermon Study on 2 Cor. 4. 3-6. Theo. Laetsch ......•..• , 30 Dispositionen ueber die erste von del' Synodalkonferenz angenommene Evangelienreihe .................... 39 Miscellanea . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 51 Theological Observer. - Kirchlich-Zeitgeschichtliches. . . . . 55 Book Review. - Literatur. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . 73 Ein Prediger 1I1U88 n1eht aIleln ID.~, also dUs er die Schafe unterwelae, wi. ole rechte Christen lO11en seln. sondem ouch daneben den Woe1fen weMen, da.se iie die Schafe nicht ancrelfen und mit falacher Lehre Tertuehren und Irrtum ein· fuehren. -'- Luther. E. at keln Ding, daa die Leute mehr bel der Kirch. behaelt denn die gute Predigt. - ~polollia. ~rt . t .. It the trumpet giTe an uncertain lOund, wbo oball prepare himself to the battle? 1 COf'. ~. 8. Published for the Ev. Luth. Synod of JIlissouri, Ohio, and Other States COB'COBl):u. PtrBLISHDfG HOtrSE, St. Louis, Mo. CHIVE Concordia Theological Monthly Vol. VII JANUARY, 1936 No.1 Testifying the Gospel of the Grace of God.* Whenever St. Paul had occasion to speak of his work in the Ohristian ministry, his thoughts dwelt on one subject: "The Gospel of the grace of God." At a conference at Miletus he characterized his ministry thus: "None of these things move me, neither count I my life dear unto myself, so that I might finish my course with joy and the ministry which I have received of the Lord Jesus, to testify the Gospel of the grace of God," Acts 20, 24. On the present occasion we cannot, and we would not, speak on any other subject. Let us single out this particular point: The great need, the one great need, of the Ohurch is "the Gospel of the grace of God." The Ohurch owes its existence to the Gospel of the grace of God. And it could not exist for one moment without it. Offering the sinner the forgiveness of sins gained by Ohrist, the Gospel produces and preserves the saving faith, and by magnifying this wondrous love of God, it produces the Ohristian life. In the words of Dr. Pieper (Okr. Dog., II, p. 13): "The gratuitus favor Dei P1"Opte7' Oh1"istum, brought to us in the Gospel, is the immovable heaven of grace spread out over the Ohurch, under which the Ohristians live and work by faith. Gazing upon this heaven of grace, faith comes into being, is preserved, and becomes a 'living, energetic, active, mighty thing' (Luther, XIV, 99)." We Ohristians owe everything to the grace of God. It is the one source and the rich source of all comfort and joy. When the sinner, when the Ohristian, realizes his utter unworthiness and absolute helplessness, the Gospel speaketh in this wise: "By grace are ye saved, .. . not of yourselves, ... not of works," Eph. 2, 8 f. - sola gmtia. When we anxiously inquire by what right the just God receives the sinner into His favor, the Gospel speaketh in this wise: * The following address, delivered October 25, 1935, in the chapel of Concordia Seminary on the occasion of Dr. L. Fuerbringer's jubilee, is offered here in place of the customary Foreword to the CONCORDIA THEOLOGICAL MONTHLY. The sole business of our periodical is to testify the Gospel of the grace of God. - Ed. Nate. 1 2 Testifying the Gospel of tIle Grace of God. Ye are "justified freely by His grace, through the redemption that is in Ohrist Jesus," Rom. 3,24 - iwvor Dei propte1' Christwn. And to him who, happy in the joy of salvation, has but one more wish, the eager desire to have his fellow-men share in his bliss, the Gospel speaketh in this wise: "Preach the Gospel to every creature," Mark 16, 15. "The grace of God that bringeth salvation hath appeared to all 1nen," Titus 2, 11 - gndia univeTsalis. The grace of God in Ohrist is everything to the Ohurch. And so much does she make of the truth that her righteousness is Ohrist that it has become her very name. "This is the name wherewith she shall be called: The Lord Our Righteousness," J er. 33, 16. That means, as a theologian who is still among us, near and dear to us, points out: "The Ohurch of God is set before us as a monument of joy, and the name that she bears, the mark by which she is known, is the name of her Savior, Jehovah Zid7cenu, the Lord Our Righteousness." (Lehre 1)'nd WehTe, 74, p. 145.) The Gospel of the grace of God is the Ohurch's all. In it she lives and moves and has her being. The Gospel supplies every want of the Ohurch and can remedy every evil that affiicts her. For instance, the Ohurch is groaning under the divisions which the errorists have caused in the visible Ohurch. The heart of every Ohristian is set on the removal of this curse. And the only power that can heal the hurt is the Gospel of the grace of God. Says Luther (v, 1170), and after him the Formula of Ooncord (TrigZ., p. 917): "If this only article remains pure on the battle-field, the Ohristian Ohurch also remains pure and in goodly harmony and without any sects; but if it does not remain pure, it is not possible that any error or fanatical spirit can be resisted." The reason is this: "Es kann 7ceine Ketzerei die Gnade Gottes leiden." (Luther, III, 1692.) The errorist, at heart, hates the article that man is saved, converted, justified, by grace alone. (Op. Walther, Law and Gospel, p.163.) And, conversely, the heart that lives in the grace of God lcann 7ceine K etzeTei Zeiclen. It cannot bear any false teaching. FOT, since the article of the grace of God is the heart and center of the entire Scriptures, any denial of any Scripture-teaching will in the end vitiate this article. And that the Christian cannot stand. - How shall the disrupted Ohurch be re- united? Let the Gospel of grace Tule in theology and rule in the hearts; then men will not only be able to detect the particular error, but will also be ready and determined to cast it out of their hearts, out of theology, out of the Ohurch. The Ohurch's one great need is the Gospel of the grace of God, and so, in the second place, she needs a ministry which is able and willing to testify and teach it. And the Gospel itself supplies this need. No man becomes a minister of the Gospel of himself. It is not. an easy matter to testify and teach the Gospel of grace. That arouses Testifying the Gospel of the Graee of God. 3 the opposition and enmity of well-nigh the whole world. The whole Pelagian world is up in arms against it. The Pelagian world of Paul's days was determined to silence this testimony. Paul could testify the Gospel of grace only at the cost of bonds and affiiction and at the daily risk of his life. Moreover, it went against his own Pelagian flesh and blood. It needed the power of God to turn the Pelagian Pharisee Paul into a minister of the Gospel of grace. It was the power of God which made the Semi-Pelagian, Oatholic Luther a preacher of the righteousness which is of faith, by grace. And this compelling, gently compelling, force inheres in the Gospel itself. It was the Gospel which won the heart of Paul and thereby at onee enlisted his mind and tongue and pen in its service. The joy of salvation which it brought to him must be brought to others. "Salva- tion unto us has come by God's free grace and favor" - we cannot keep that song locked up in our hearts. The earth must be £lled with the psalm of sola gratia, gratia universalis. The Gospel of grace produces its own heralds. The pastors who had met there in Jl,i[iletus were facing the same difficulties and struggles that Paul had en- countered, and he tells them.: "I commend you to God and to the Word of His grace, which ii:> able to build you up," Acts 20, 32. The Gospel produces the men the Ohurch needs, and the Ohurch needs men who live for the Gospel and are ready to die for it. Such men, dedicated to the Gospel, live in the Gospel. It is their daily meditation. They pray, says Luther, that "the Holy Ghost may so fin their hearts with it that they busy themselves with it all the day long, that they retire with these words at night and rise with them in the morning." (XI, 1103.) Further, "a preacher of the right sort studies and teaches this article above all and at all times; for on this article depends the true knowledge of God and our salvation." (VIII, 798.) A preacher of the right sort knows only one thing. Paul "determined not to know anything save Jesus Ohrist, and Him crucified," 1001'.2,2. Whether he preached in the market-place, or wrote epistles to the churches, or trained men for the ministry, or supervised their later work, his one interest lay in the Gospel of grace. Such a min- ister has no time to waste on anything that does not very positively serve the Gospel of grace. Other studies may gain him the plaudits of the learned, other activities arouse the admiration and enthusiastic support of the secularistic and legal-minded masses. But none of these things move him. Finally, he jealously guards the purity of the Gospel of grace as the one treasure of tho Ohurch, the only hope of the sinner. He would rather cut off his right hand than write down one word in support of the teaching that there is something in man, some activity, some disposition, that merits, or accounts for, the sin- ner's conversion. He would rather have his tongue paralyzed than have it say that God would not have all men to be saved. He will not 4 Testifying the Gospel of the Grace of God. commit the crime of closing the door of heaven to any sinner and of robbing the troubled believer of his needed comfort. "That does the Church need? Her prayer is: Lord, give us men who testify the Gospel, the full and pure Gospel. The Ohurch needs to have the Gospel of grace preached to her, preached, in the third place, in the Lutheran way. There are not different kinds of Gospel- the Oatholic gospel, the Reformed gospel, the Modernist gospel, the Lutheran gospel. There is but one Gospel- salvation because of Ohrist, salvation by grace alone, salvation for all. And this Gospel is preached by the Lutheran Ohurch in all its fulness and purity. She has maintained the article of grace in all its parts and aspects, in all its bearings and relations. Her enemies bear witness to that effect. For on that account they are her enemies. They blame her just for this. The liberal bodies hate the Lutheran Ohurch for teaching the gratia Dei propter Ohristum. The Oatholic and Arminian churches blame her for teaching the sola gratia. The Oalvinistic churches call her to account for teaching the gratia ~miversalis. This is the verdict of the adversaries. "This blessed doctrine [of the right- eousness of faith in Ohrist], the .precious holy Gospel, they call Lu- theran." (Apology. Trigl., p. 327.) Yes, whatever belongs to the Biblical doctrine of saving grace the Lutheran Ohurch teaches. She will not relinquish one iota of it. "Of this article nothing can be yielded or surrendered, even though heaven and earth and whatever will not abide, should sink to ruin." (Smale. Art. Trigl., p.461.) She cannot do otherwise. She will not go against God's eternal truth. She solemnly declares: "IVe have said in the Oonfession that the remission of sins is received freely for Ohrist's sake, through faith. If this is not the very voice of the Gospel, if it is not the judgment of the eternal Father, which Thou who art in the bosom of the Father hast revealed to the world, we are justly blamed. But Thy death is a witness, Thy resurrection is a witness, the Holy Ghost is a witness, Thy entire Ohurch is a witness that it is truly the judgment of the Gospel that we obtain remission of sins, not on account of our merits, but on account of Thee, through faith." (Apology. Trigl., p.423.) The one need of the Ohurch is the Gospel of grace, and the more fully this Gospel is l)reached, the better her need is supplied. If the voice of the Lutheran Ohurch were hushed, that is to say, if the Gospel of grace were no longer preached in its fulness and purity, the Ohu1'ch would suffer great spiritual loss. Amplifying this, Dr. Krauth de- clared: "As our Ohurch has been needed in the past, so she is l1nedec1 in the present. She is needed not only for her motherhood to her own children, but for the great wants of Ohristendom and of the world. She is needed as a witness to that doctrine which is conceded in terms by the whole Protestant world, but which is invaded primarily or by necessary inference by every system which is at war with ours - Testifying the Gospel of the Grace of God. 5 the doctrine of justification by faith. Inadequate views of the person and work of Ohrist; false views of election and reprobation; of the means of grace; of the Word and Sacraments; of the mode and subject of Baptism; of the nature of the validity and efficacy of the ministry- all are in conflict, covertly it may be, but really, with the true doctrine of justification by faith. Romanism and Ritualism directly assail it; Rationalism destroys it; Fanaticism, sometimes with an affectation of zealotry for it, confounds justification by faith with justification by sensation and leads the patient to rest, not on the old, eternal promise, but on a new personal observation. No Ohurch holds the doctrine of justification by faith in that consistent integrity and harmonious relation within itself and with all other doctrines in which it is held and confessed in the Lutheran Ohurch." (The Lu- theran Diet, 1877, p. 48.) Finally. One of the instrumentalities through which the I"utheran Ohurch fulfils her God-given mission is our Ooncordia Seminary together with its sister seminaries throughout the world. In view of the nature of the present celebration a few remarks on this point will not be out of Jllace. Ooncordia Seminary has one single aim - to fit men for the ministry of the Gospel of grace, to graduate men who are able and willing to 'preach it in its purity and fulness. Its first president, Dr. Walther, inculcated this from first to last. "The weakest graduate, if only he has grasped the doctrine that the gI'ace of God in Ohrist Jesus has appeared for all men, to be received freely, by faith, can preach to men in such a way that they are assured of their salvation, and that is worth more than all the wisdom and all the possessions and treasures of the world. What is all erudition, as necessary as it is in its place, compared with the wisdom of God which is set forth when but the simple passage is explained 'God so loved the world,' etc.? Heari~g this, all poor sinners rejoice, all the holy angels are filled with wonder, and the whole world should sink upon its knees and sing Gloria and Hallelujah. If our young preachers preach this, they are the men who can start a reformation in our country, as indeed in this way a small beginning has already been made." (Proc. Syn. Coni., 1872, p. 28.) He told his students: "If you preach the Gospel abundantly, ... your people will say: 'Our minister has given us what we could not get anywhere else. He is a true Lutheran minister and pours out a great treasure for us every Sunday.'" (Law and Gospel, p.408.) And we know with what burn- ing words he adjured the Seminary, at the dedication in 1883, to remain true to its charter. (Cf. Lutheraner, 79, p.372.) The second president, Dr. Pieper, ever reminded the Seminary of its high calling. In an essay read before the General Body in 1926 he said: "The new Seminary buildings here in St. Louis are placed in the service of the Christian doctrine of grace. If they did not serve that purpose, 6 '!let ~ietiSntus. they would be nothing but a magnificent idol-temple." He closed his essay with the prayer: "Dear Savior Jesus Ohrist, graciously grant us that we may never betray the alone-saving Ohristian doctrine of grace, but remain faithful confessors of it for the honor of Thy holy name and the salvation of man! Amen." (Lehre und WeMe, 72, pp. 266. 329.) By the grace of God, Ooncordia Seminary to-day knows only one thing. The Biblical doctrine of the grace of God in Ohrist shapes all the courses in its curriculum. It forms the subject of the final examinations. Addressing the graduating class of 1933, the president said: "We feel sure that you have a clear perception of these two central truths of our Ohurch, of the formal principle [the sole authority of Scripture] and of the material principle [justifica- tion by faith, salvation by grace], and that you confess both by mouth and heart as your faith; otherwise we could not with a good con- science permit you to enter the ministry." (OONC. THEOL. MONTHLY, IV, 562). A seminary of this character, in so far as it accomplishes its high aim, measures up fully to the needs of the Ohurch. And now for the matter at hand. Realizing the need of the Ohurch and of the world, we commemorate with gratitude and joy the fifty years of Dr. Fuerbringer's work in the ministry of the Gospel of grace. In all these years, in the various positions into which God placed him, as pastor of a Ohristian congregation, as teacher at Oon- cordia Seminary since 1893 and its president since 1931, as editor of the Luthemner, and as President of the Synodical Oonference, making full use of the manifold opportunities these positions offered, he has been testifying with a loud and sweet voice the Gospel of the grace of God; he has been giving all that is in him to supply the one great need of the Ohurch. We thank God for the rich blessings this ministration has brought to us and countless others. And we pray God that the teaching and the example of the jubilarian may inspire many with the mind of the apostle: "None of these things move me, neither count I my life dear unto myself, so that I might finish my course with joy and the ministry which I have received of the Lord Jesus to testify the Gospel of the grace of God." TH. ENGELDER. ~et ~iett~m1t~. (\:3'0 rtf e~ung.) ~n ben "IDlagbefmrger 2en±Urien", bem monumenialen ®elcljicljg~ tDert ber meformct±ion~3eii, abgefcljloffen im ~aqre 1574, fcljrieb 1Yraciu~: "Wnfiatt e i n e ~ !j3aWe~ llJringen iqrer un3iiqtige qeruor, tDeIclje meclji umtDecljfetn unb au~ ®ericljg~ in ~ircljenfacljen treien, in iqren @5cljran~ fen niclji bIdben unb ben ®emeinben bie ®lauben~formern mit @5cljtDeri, mw~ unb SDonner aUfbringen. SDa3u brauclj± man einen &)aufen mor~