Concoll()ia Theological Montbly APRIL 1951 ARCHIVE C o n c o J l ~ i o Theological M o n t b l ~ Published by The Lutheran Church -Missouri Synod EDITED BY THE FACULTY OF CONCORDIA SEMINARY ST. LOUIS, Mo. Address all communications to Ih6 Editorial Committee in CMe 0/ the Managing EditDr, P.E.Ma'JH, 801 De Mun At/e., St.Louis 5, Mo. EDITORIAL COMMITTEE CONTENTS PAUL M BRETSCHER, RICHARD R. CABMMERER, THEODORE HoYER, FREDERICK E. MAyER, LOUIS J. SIECK FOR APRIL 1951 PAGE THE AUTHORSHIP OF ST. JOHN'S GOSPEL. Hugo Odeberg 225 THE TEMPTATION OF THE CHURCH: A STUDY OF MArr.4: 1-11. J. J. Pelikan, Jr. 251 THE LOTTHERS: FORGOTTEN PRINTERS OF THE REFORMATION W. G. Tillmanns 260 SERMON STUDY ON ISAIAH 6: 1-8 265 THEOLOGICAL OBSERVER 275 I BOOK REVIEW 294 Francisco, Clyde T.: Introducing the Old Testament. -Heidel, Alexander: The Gilgamesch Epic and Old Testament Parallels. -Callaway, T. W.: Christ in the I Old Testament. -:-Allis, Oswald T.: The Unity of Isaiah. -Way, Arthur S. i (translator): The Letters of St. Paul to Seven Churches and Three Friends with the Letter to the Hebrews. -Uttle, C. H.: Explanation of the Book of Revelation.Blert, Werner von: Das christliche Ethos.-Henry, Carl F. H.: Fifty Years of i Protestant Theology. -Carnell, Bdward J.: The Theology of Reinhold Niebuhr. ' -Schlink, B., et al.: Evangelisches Gutachten zur Dogmatisierung der Leiblichen Himmelfahrt Marias. -Sangster, W. B.: The Craft of Sermon Illustration.Kennard, J. Spencer, Jr.: Render to God. A Study of the Tribute Passage.Calhoun, Arthur Wallace: The Cultural Concept of Christianity. CONCORDIA THEOLOGICAL MONTIn.V is published monthly by Concordia Publishing I House, 3558 S. Jefferson Ave., St. Louis 18, Mo., to which all business correspondence is to be addressed. . $3.00 per annum, anywhere in the world, payable in advance.", Entered at the Post Office at St. Louis, Mo., as second·class matter. Acceptance for' mailing at special rate of postage provided for in Section 1103, Act of October 3. 1917, i authorized on July 5, 1918. PllNnD n< 17. s. A. ~ O d c o r 1 i ) i a Tbeological J \ ! ' O ' J { i ~ l y VOL. XXII APRIL 1951 No.4 The Authorship of St. John's Gospel By PROFESSOR HUGO ODEBERG Professor Hugo Odeberg, D. D., Ph. D., who made the present article available to our journal, is professor of New Testament interpretation at the University of Lund, Sweden. He is widely known as the author of The Fourth Gospel (Uppsala och Stockholm, 1929), as chief consultant of Brevna, a Swedish theological journal interested in conservative Biblical studies, and as contributor to other theological journals. He is a recognized authority on Rabbinical literature. The present article was translated from Swedish into English by Miss J. Guinness and edited by P. M. B . . r-\ OME New Testament books contain clear statements as to who I ~ wrote them. Oftentimes the author's name is mentioned at the beginning of the book. This is natural when it is an Epistle, for it is usual to specify in a letter both by whom it is written, and to whom it is sent. Most New Testament Epistles begin with the name of the sender and also mention the name or names of those to whom the Letter is addressed. The Epistle to the Galatians, for instance, opens with the author's name: "Paul, an Apostle ... to the churches of Galatia." The writer not only gives his name, but also adds a personal attribute which proves his identity. The first Epistle of Peter, too, begins: "Peter, an Apostle of Jesus Christ, to the elect who are sojourners in the Dispersion in Pontus, Galatia, Cappadocia, Asia, and Bithynia." The Epistle of Jude begins: "Judas, a servant of Jesus Christ, and brother of James, to them that are called." Other New Testament books, besides the Epistles, also contain in instances definite information regarding their authorship. Revelation, for example, states unmistakably and explicitly that its author is the John who was once banished to the Isle of Patmos. "I John, your brother and partaker with you in the tribulation and kingdom and patience which are in Jesus, was in the isle that is called Patmos, for the Word of God and the testimony of Jesus" (Rev. 1:9). 226 THE AUTHORSHIP OF JOHN'S GOSPEL But there are other New Testament writings, and among them some written in the form of Epistles, which do not reveal their authorship. The Epistle to the Hebrews opens without mentioning either the name of the writer or of those to whom it is sent. The same applies to the First Epistle of John. Of the four Gospels, Matthew and Mark are entirely anonymous. Also the Gospel of Luke does not state the author's name. Yet in its opening sentences the writer speaks in the first person singular, addressing the one to whom his Gospel is dedicated, thus taking it for granted that the writer was personally known to the addressee. There are, however, other writings which, though they are neither entirely anonymous nor identify the writer by name, yet indicate so clearly who he is that it is impossible to call his identity in question. Among these are the Second and Third Epistles of John and the book which we are about to approach, the Gospel of John. The author of the Second and Third Epistles of John was known to contemporary readers, since the sender is named as o : r r Q E <