Concoll()ia Tbeological Monthly SEPTEMBER 1950· ARCHIVE Instructions to the Weak and the Strong According to Romans 14 By C. A. GAERTNER ETERNAL vigilance is the price of Christian liberty which was restored to Christendom through the Lutheran Reformation. Legalism and license always have been and still are the implacable foes of Christian liberty and ultimately of the Gospel itself. Since the Apostolic days church history is replete with instances where entire church bodies fell victi..'1l to one or the other. And the pity is that only too frequently matters of indifference, so-called adiaphora, served as the starting point from which either legalism or license sabotaged the priceless boon of Christian liberty. The Lutheran Church must therefore guard with espeCial care its great heritage of the proper distinction between Law and Gospel if it would retain its liberty. Eternal vigilance must be the watchword also of the local congregation_ It is on the congregational level where either legalism or license frequently manifests itself in determining the Christian's attitude toward purely indifferent matters. There may be honest differences of opinion in fixing the borderline between right and wrong in many of the problems which confront the Christian in his family, his social and business contacts, and even in his congregation and synod. Some of the Christians at Rome became exercised over the matter of whether or not it was permissible to eat certain types of meat. In our society Christians may clash in their views concerning such adiaphora as the proper observance of Sunday and "closed seasons," chutch rites, tithing, the frequency of attendance at the Lord's Supper, clerical vestments, forms of amusement which are per se not sinful. Lest the agitation over such and many similar adiaphora lead to the loss of Christian liberty and of the Gospel, pastor and people must carefully heed the instructions which St. Paul lays down in Romans 14. These instructions are based on inviolable principles and are as true today as when Paul penned them. 659 660 INSTRUCTIONS TO THE WEAK AND THE STRONG It must be noted at the outset that in this chapter St. Paul is dealing with real adiaphora. It is of course understood that under certain conditions the principle: Nihil est adiaphoron in casu confessionis et scandali (Formula of Concord, Art. X) must be applied. For example, the form of applying water in Baptism, whether by immersion, sprinkling, or pouring is in itself an adiaphoron. We can therefore find no fault with a Christian if he, like luther, prefers immersion. It is therefore certainly not unscriptural if under certain circumstances a lutheran pastor would depart from the customary form of Baptism and baptize an adult convert by immersion. However, if he insists on immersion because of erroneous views concerning the essence and purpose of Baptism, then the form of Bapti m ceases to be an adiaphoron and becomes a matter of confession. Immersion may also become a matter of offense, inasmuch as our Lutherans who rightly view the form of pouring as a confessional matter would be confused. Or take the case of liturgical forms, clerical vestments, and similar adiaphora. If the introduction of new forms causes our people to suspect that some un-lutheran doctrine lurks behind the new ceremony, then ceremonies cease to be adiaphora because they cause confusion and may even become a scandal, an occasion for some Christian to lose his faith. In Romans 14, however, Paul is not speaking of such matters, but restricts his discussion to the Christian's attitude toward genuine and real adiaphora. I. INSTRUCTIONS TO THE WEAK BRETHREN A proper application of the principles laid down by St. Paul requires that we know whom Paul has in mind when he speaks of "him that is weak in the faith." We frequently call those members "weak Christians" who are easily misled into sin, whose faith is weak, who are negligent in the use of the means of grace. However in Romans 14 the word n;Lcrn<; does not denote the Spiritwrought conviction that Christ is the Savior from sin. Here it is used to express ethical conviction, or moral persuasion. In other words, Paul is describing the weakness in knowing what a Christian mayor may not do; or very simply, his failure to understand the essence of Christian liberty. They are fearful Christians lest they do wrong in something of which they are not sure. They are weak INSTRUCTIONS TO THE WEAK AND THE STRONG 661 brethren because they lack the Scriptural knowledge and understanding concerning indifferent matters, the adiaphora. This interpretation of "weak in the faith" is the only one possible when we take into consideration the re t of this chapter. The weak brother is described as one who does not eat meat, but only herbs. He is afraid he may defile hin1self by eating meat. Possibly some of them had scruples concerning meat eating, because some meats were forbidden as unclean in the Ceremonial Law. Or perhaps some were afraid that the meat offered for food had been offered originally to some of the idols by the heathen and that therefore it might not be right to partake of it. Whatever the reason may have been, they were afraid they would sin by eating meat, or they thought that they could be spiritually stronger by refraining from meat eating. Some of these "weak in the faith" are also described as people who se lected s p ~ ~ c i <