Full Text for CTM Book Review 12-4 (Text)
l
. dEI~ dm Wo.!·
llin "'.h ...... d:u: ~ ~ .. h"" Irll!bt
~lID.lmd mit ta!Jo:bcr Lrl, Vtl_
fIuohrm m:d lM=I elnfuehnn.
."' ...
- -'"
313
EI bt btu Dtq _ en. WIlt.
III.OU bd .s. ItIRbl t.bacll dean
die 111M PndJJL-ApokIgiot. ht.zt
U thII tN/,'flW\ """ ... Ull<:Crfa!t
_ do who WU prepue hlmalI
ttl, baW .. ' _I c~ If:'
Publbhed for the
Ev. Luth Synod of Mlssonri, Ohio, and Other SUtes
CONCORDIA Pl.iBLISlIDiG Hoes' Sf. Lou.! Mo.
A, ,
Book Review - i!itetGtut 318
Book Review - 5!itertttur
All books reviewed In this periodical may be pnic:ured from or through COD.-
cordia Publlshlng Bouse, 3558 S. Jefferson Ave., St. Louis, Mo.
The Hope of the Ages. The Messianic Hope in Revelation, in History,
and in Realization. By Arno Clemens Gaebelein, D. D. "Our
Hope," 456 Fourth Ave., New York, N. Y. 187 pages, 5%XSl/4.
Price, $1.00.
The theme of this volume is the hope of the second advent, a subject
which requires a profound knowledge of the Scriptures, especially of
the prophecies related to the New Testament age. Dr. Gaebelein is one
of the leading fundamentalist theologians and like most of these is a
millenarian. With much in this volume we must disagree. Dr. Gaebelein
terms the belief current at the time of Christ that His return would
bring a universal resurrection "unscriptural." He denies that the
Papacy is Antichrist. His millennialism is based upon predicating a
literal fulfilment for the prophecies in which the spiritual glories of
the New Testament Church are being described by Old Testament
writers and in Revelation. In spite of the definite reference of Amos
9: 11-15 to the New Testament Church vindicated in Acts 15, he refers
this fundamental text to a universal conversion of the Jews, with dis-
tinctly chiliastic background. Dr. Gaebelein certainly ignores the testi-
mony of history when he calls the amillennialists theological "new-
comers." Nor do we believe that it was the chiliastic hope that kept
alive the faith of Christendom through the early age of persecution.
He gains Scriptural ground for his chiliasm only by importing the idea
into texts which bear no such connotation, as when he interprets the
sleeping of the five foolish virgins as the Church's loss of the millenni~
hope (p. 133). Dr. Gaebelein rejects the doctrine of baptismal regenera-
tion (p. 135). He distinguishes a "false chiliasm" from the "true," the
false type being exhibited in the Anabaptist movement, and it is to
this alone that he refers the condemnation of chiliasm in the Protestant
symbols. More than once (Melanchthon, p. 145; Milton, p. 151) he cites
the belief of Protestant leaders in the Second Coming in support of
chiliasm. Dr. Gaebelein does not represent the carnal type of the mil-
lennial doctrine, and his book is a valuable source for all who wish to
acquaint themselves with modern chiliasm as held by its representatives
in the fundamentalist group. TH. GRAEBNER
The Bible and Things to Come. By David Freeman. Zondervan Pub-
lishing Co., Grand Rapids, Mich. 139 pages, 5% X7%. Price, $1.00.
Rev. D. Freeman is pastor of the New Covenant Presbyterian Church,
Philadelphia, Pa., and a former student of the late Dr. J. G. Machen,
professor at Westminster Theological Seminary, whose views he voices
on the eschatological questions which he deals with in the nine sermons
presented in his book. The subjects he treats are: ''The Second Coming
of Christ," "When Will Christ Come?" ''The Signs of Christ's Coming;"
''The Jews, Their Conversion and Their Land," ''The Man of Sin," "Will
314 Book Review - 2itet4tut
There Be a Millennium?" "After Death- What?" ''The Day of Judg-
ment," "The Final State." While the author rejects the millennium
because it is taught neither by Scripture nor the Christian Confessions,
he believes that "Israel as a nation, in the collective sense, is to be saved
before Christ comes" (p. 69), though he holds neither that all Jews will
be saved nor that the Jewish' converts will return as a nation to the
land of Israel. "The Jews will be saved as a nation, but only in the
way in which they are converted now" (p. 77). The writer is wrong
in stressing the racial or national conversion of the Jews; for just as
the "fulness of the Gentiles" (Rom. 11: 25) refers to the elect among the
heathen, so the "all Israel" (v. 26) clearly refers to the elect of God
among the Jews. He is right, however, in his judgment that insistence
upon a literal interpretation of Old Testament eschatological prophecy
results in downright absurdities. (pp. 70, 71.) Regarding the Man of
Sin the author rejects the traditional verdict of the Church that Anti-
christ has been revealed in the Papacy, contending that Antichrist is
yet to appear, and this shortly before Christ's second coming, though for
his view he can offer no substantial proof. Except for these two points
the sermons represent the eschatological doctrines of the general Chris-
tian confessions, and their simple, yet thorough doctrinal treatment makes
them_absorbing and profitable reading. Praiseworthy above all is the
author's sanity in expounding prophecy in the light of the clear Scrip-
ture-passages; commendable are his acquaintance with, and his emphasis
on,the Bible as the sole rule of faith. The reviewer wishes to stress this
in spite of the lapses noted above. J. THEODORE MUELLER
Know the Truth. By Rev. Joseph A. Cottam, Ph. D. American Tract
Society. 259 pages, 5lhx8. Price, $1.50.
This book deals with the fundamentals of the Christian religion,
summarized on page 110 thus: "A Christ Divine, an Atonement
vicarioUs, and a Bible inspired," and on page 139 thus: "The develop-
ment of the grand thought of a substitute for the sinner embraces the
distinctive truths, the essential doctrines of Christianity; justification
by faith, atonement, redemption, imputation, the divinity of the blessed
Redeemer, the infinite grace, and the absolute effectiveness of the work
done for the deliverance of the transgressors of the divine Law." Much
of what is said in these weighty subjects is of great value. But some
is of· little value and some harmful. Frequently there is a lack of
theological precision (see, for instance, the order in which the doctrines
are listed in the citation from page 139), and there is a good deal of
halting and faltering and floundering. One cannot understand why
our author, who believes that "our Lord took up our sins and expiated
them on the cross," "reconciled the world by means of reparation, or
satisfaction offered," "that every claim of justice has been met and
satisfied," could still pen these words: "We have in circulation the idea
that Christ died because God was insulted and must punish somebody
for it or that the Atonement was the propitiation of an angry God, who
let off the rogue while He tortured the innocent." (Chapter VII.) Our
author speaks emphatically of ''the divinity of the Book,'" which "is
divinely inspired," "the written Word of God," but in chapter XV he
makes the fatal concession: "Such minor discrepancies, or errors, are
Book Review - ~iterQtUt 315
not worth mentioning as compared with the substantial reliability of
the whole records. Dr. Marcus Dods has well said: 'We are not con-
tending for an absolute literal infallibility, for any such discrepancies
avail nothing to discredit the true infallibility of the Holy Scriptures.'''
He rejects "the theory of evolution" and states that "in the first chapter
of Genesis the Bible speaks with authority, clearly, and finally on a
matter of biology. The words 'after its kind' reveal a sound biological
principle," etc. He holds, however, that "slow creation requires God
just as much as instantaneous creation. . .. Genesis condenses age-
long processes into swift acts, withdraws the mind from intermediate
stages, and sums up the whole into 'days' revealing the eternal God
as the Fountain of all." (Chap. V.) Chapter VIII, on Repentance, reflects
the confusion which Reformed theology has cast about this term.
"'Repent ye and believe in the Gospel.' Our Lord here commands the
two things which are required for salvation. The first demand He
made on men was the demand to 'repent'; the other was 'to believe.''' ...
And "repentance is a thoroughgoing movement of the whole being away
from sin and towards the love and service of God." Then we have the
statement: "There may be conversion without regeneration" (p. 155),
and, worst of all, the statement: "We must consider faith as the exercise
of man's freedom in accepting God's grace" (p. 136). In Chapter XVI,
"Know that Christ is Coming," we have this fine statement: "Spurgeon
used to say, 'There are some people who are so taken up with the second
coming of Christ that they forget to preach about the first.''' There
are millennialists who speak ~d preach of nothing but this fabled mil-
lennium. Our author avoids this extreme. But he commits this fatal
error, common to all moderate millennialists: wrapped up in the glories
of the millenniwn, they have little to say of the glory of heaven. In this
whole chapter "heaven" is mentioned but once, incidentally, in a quoted
poem. And there is no chapter on heaven. As far as this book knows,
the millenniwn is the final consummation. "The present age is to be
followed by 'an age of glory,''' when "the saints are to reign with Christ
and the rule of Christ and His people will secure immeasured blessedness
for the world. . .. We are to look for an era when the true full life
of humanity will be realized. This is the age that will dawn at the
coming of the King, ... the recreation of the social order." Finally, we
call attention to the statement: "Does our Lord ever ask those who
would belong to His kingdom to subscribe to a creed?" (P.133.) Dr. Cot-
tam is pastor of a community church in Philadelphia, and community
churches have no use for "creeds." We are wondering why Dr. Cottam
would write a book defending the Apostolic Creed and the creed of
the Reformed Church and the creed of the millennialists.
TH. ENGELDER
Naturalism. By James Bissett Pratt. Yale University Press, New Haven,
Conn. 180 pages, including Index, 51f2X8%. Price, $2.00.
This new volwne on Naturalism offers the third series of the Powell
Lectures on Philosophy at Indiana University, delivered in 1938 by the
well-known professor of philosophy at Williams College, its predecessors
being The Lasting Elements in Individualism (W. E. Hocking) and In the
Spirit of William James (R.B.Perry). Naturalism, in philosophy, has
316 Baok Review - 2iteratur
been defined as the doctrine which denies all evidence far a spiritual
creative and uphalding principle and far a universal telealagy, explaining
the warld whally aut of the cambinatian of material elements acting
under physical laws. This papular definitian .of Mechanistic Naturalism
(New StandaTd DictionaTY) does nat adequately describe the empirical
Naturalism championed by the authar, wha in his four lectures presents
Naturalism in its fundamental canceptian, its relatian to life and evalu-
tian, to mind, and finally to marality and religian. Personally he
repudiates the traditianal crude and static Naturalism in favar of a mare
critical, empirical form, which is "always ready ta learn." In the end,
it is true, Naturalism cares little to learn, since it rejects as impassible
all supernatural data and explains the universe in its develapment and
existence merely by impersanal principles. Though talerant .otherwise,
the authar becames bitterly sarcastic when he speaks .of the "gaad .old
days .of particular Pravidences and singing spheres and anthrapomarphic
deities." (P. 45.) Ta him man and animal are praducts cif fundamental
forces thraugh pracess .of evalutian. Disavawing Mechanism and Neo-
Lamarckianism as inadequate and inclining persanally ta Vitalism ("Same
force ather than the physical and chemical directs the biolagical activities
.of the .organism and the caurse .of racial evalutian," p. 76), he laaks upan
the universe as an ".organic being, dominated by definite tendencies of
immanent purpose." (P.93.) Since the Casmas is thus "permeated with
immanent purpose and is therefare a telealagical and also a spiritual
.organism" (p. 142), crass Materialism must yield to an intelligent
Idealism, in which Mind finds bath an explanation and justificatian and
in which there is a place far Marality as an evaluatian .of all "pleasurable
consequences" (pp. 158 ff.). So alsa Religian, raated in the cancept
.of an organic and telealagical universe (p. 175) and finding its "gad"
in nature ("Deus sive N atuTa") , becames exceedingly real to the empirical
Naturalist, Gad being the "Real as such." Far His reality in this sense
there exists "an unanswerable ontalagical demanstratian." Dr. Pratt's
lectures are valuable because, an the .one hand, they clarify many maat
paints an the subject and, an the ather, assign in Naturalism a place
to deity and warship. Of caurse, the Naturalistic deity is na mare than
Nature itself and the worship na mare than pagan, pantheistic warship .of
the creature rather than the Creator. Naturalism therefore rejects all
true religian and the true Gad and as such remains unspeakably com-
fartless and hapeless in its inherent pessimism, thus .offering anather
praof .of the total bankruptcy of perverted reason left ta itself, without
the guidance and strength .of divine revelatian.
J. THEODORE MtTELLER
The World Today. A Challenge to the Christian Church. By Alfred M.
Rehwinkel, M. A., B. D., Professar .of Theolagy, Cancardia Semi-
nary, St. Louis, Mo. Concordia Publishing House, St. Louis, Mo.
107 pages. Price, 50 cts., postpaid.
Rarely does the title of a book describe its cantents so exactly and
completely. In these lectures, originally presented to the Atlantic Dis-
trict .of the Missauri Synod, the authar describes conditions in the world
today, comparing them with conditians in the past, reaching aut widely
into the whale field of World and Church Histary and drawing there-
Book Review -13ittratur 317
from lessons for our consideration as we look forward into the future.
The conclusions he draws as he views "The Political and International
World, The Social and Economic World, The Religious World" are some-
times encouraging, sometimes alarming, always stimulating. Concordia
Publishing House has reissued the essays in an attractive booklet at
a !low price, which should encourage a wide distribution. A detailed
subject index will make it especially useful as a reference for the pastor
and lecturer. THEo. HOYER
Cross-Examined. By Edward Kuhlmann. Lutheran Book Concern,
Columbus, o. 95 pages, 5X7%. Price, 85 cts.
Our Great Salvation. The Centrality of the Cross. By W. E. and E. W.
Schramm. Lutheran Book Concern, Columbus, o. 109 pages,
5X7%. Price, $1.00.
These volumes offer a number of series of Lenten discourses. The
central doctrine of the atonement through the blood of Christ is well
stressed. The various practical implications for the life of the believer
and the appeal to the unbeliever to accept Christ by faith are presented
with originality and effect.
Pastor Kuhlmann is widely known for his pleasing and helpful
literary productions for young and old. Also his sermons in this volume
have a literary flavor. The uniqueness of approach and the extreme
wealth of illustrations in these Lenten addresses make them interesting
and stimulating for the reader. Doubtless they were so preached
by the author. As models for Lenten sermons they will serve only
such pastors as can make literary allusion a part of their own personality
and can reenforce the rather slender doctrinal core of their special
addresses with abundant doctrinal content in congregational preaching,
Bible class, and other catechetical work, which no doubt the author
utilizes.
Pastor W. E. Schramm, D. D., is senior pastor of St. Mark's Church,
Butler, Pa., and has published a number of volumes of sermonic and
practical content. His series Our Great Salvation offers seven sermons
on John 3: 16. This is not as much a homiletical tour de force as may
be imagined; the material is derived from the text, is adequately factual
in doctrine, and is organized and applied with a sure hand.
Rev. E. W. Schramm is the editor of the Lutheran Standard and has
published several volumes of sermons. His series The Centrality of the
Cross is a workmanlike discussion of the Seven Words. Themes and
divisions are in some instances especially adroit.
It is not written in censure of these and similar sermons, for they
are well done, but of the use to which many preachers put them, when
we say that nothing in the way of cleverness of theme, tenuousness of
derivation of material, or originality of elaboration can replace the Gospel
minimum particularly in Lenten sermons. The tradition particularly of
preaching ever and always on the Passion-story has resulted in a tech-
nique of hypercleverness in finding applications which prevents the full
use of the opportunities which Lent provides for the preacher. Surely,
if ever, then at Lent it should be true of the Christian preacher that
he focuses, rather than obscures, the Gospel-message by his homiletic
devices. RICHARD R. CAEMMERER
318 Book Review - ~itttCltUt
Proceedings of the Thirty-Seventh Convention of the Ev. Luth. Synodical
Conference, assembled at Chicago, ill., Aug. 1-6, 1940. Concordia
Publishing House, St. Louis, Mo. 99 pages, 6X9. Price, 20 cts.
These Proceedings contain two splendid doctrinal essays. The first,
by Prof. A. Schaller of Thiensville, Wis., treats of "The Brotherhood of
Faith" as a gift of God, as a fountain of blessings, and as a sacred
responsibility. The members of the Synodical Conference are reminded
that the brotherhood of faith, the unity of faith and doctrine which
they enjoy, is a gift of the unmerited grace of God, are invited to make
full use of the blessings it offers, and are earnestly admonished to "keep
the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace." The essay naturally
touches upon the spurious brotherhood contrived by unionism. For
instance: "During the last few decades they [the Lutheran unionists]
have frankly urged the formation of one great united Lutheran brother-
hood of faith, as though such an undertaking were a matter of addition
and multiplication. Let us help our people to recognize the cheap
methods by which most men in sectarian circles strive to bring about
their proposed unions. . .. They seem to have no inkling of the fact
that God creates the brotherhood of faith. They do not recognize the
wondrous miracle that is involved. By adopting a few breezy resolutions,
they blasphemously proclaim to the world that they have brought to life
a new brotherhood of faith. . .• Fellowship of faith is never a product
of human scheming and planning. When God creates in a man the light
of the knowledge of His glory in the face of Jesus Christ, and when
in His mercy He leads him to sever relations with the ungodly or
with his associates in a sectarian church-body and to make public con-
fession of his faith with us, then, and only then, may we say that
we have won a new brother in faith. In no other way can a God-
pleasing union come about." The second essay, by Dr. Th. Laetsch of
St. Louis, Mo., treats the doctrine of "The Holiness of God." How many
of us have mastered this subject? The essay states: "Very frequently
the pastor, the teacher, the layman, does not use this term [the holiness
of God] in the fulness of its meaning, perhaps is not even conscious
of all it connotes and implies. And just as frequently the hearers do
not understand the term in all the unfathomable riches of its signifi-
cance." So let us study these points: "God's holiness manifests itself
in its transcendence over all created things." "God's holiness manifests
itself as an ethical quality in His absolute sinlessness and impeccability."
"God's holiness manifests itself in creating man in His own image, in
demanding holiness of all His creatures, in His threats directed against
every form of unholiness and every unholy person, in the temporal and
eternal punishment of all sinners," and in this: "He is also the holy
and all-merciful Savior, whose holiness is manifested in sanctifying
sinners, iD. finding ways and means to separate, to deliver the sinner
from the guilt, the penalty, and the power of sin and thus to make the
children of wrath the sons of God and heirs of eternal salvation."
(Concluding paragraph.) Make this essay an extension course in your
study of theology. It will make you a better theologian and deepen
the spiritual life of your hearers.
Book Review -~itefQtuf 3.19
The Synodical Conference thoroughly studied the question of Lu-
theran unity. The Proceedings contain the report submitted by the
Missouri Synod Committee on Lutheran Church Union, the Missouri
Synod resolutions with respect to fellowship (1938), the Sandusky
Resolutions (American Lutheran Church, 1938), the Resolutions of the
Joint Synod of Wisconsin and Other States (1939), and the Resolutions
adopted by the Synodical Conference in this matter. From these we
quote the following: "That we ask the Missouri Synod not to enter
into fellowship (prayer-, altar-, pulpit-fellowship) with the American
Lutheran Church until matters now objected to by members of the
Synodical Conference have been clarified .... " "That the presidents of
the four synods be requested to devise ways and means for continuing
close cooperation between the different union committees of the Synod-
ical Conference." "All members of the Synodical Conference should
feel in duty bound as brethren to watch and pray with those who
must bear the responsibility that no steps be taken that might in future
lead us away from the Scriptural paths which the Synodical Conference
has followed from the days of our fathers." TH. ENGELDER
Proceedings of the Twenty-First Convention of the Southern Dlinois
District. Concordia Publishing House, St. Louis, Mo., 1940.
82 pages, 5Jhx81h. Price, 12 cts.
At the convention of the Southern nIinois District Dr. H. B. Hem-
meter read an essay on "The Evangelical Lutheran Church the True
Visible Church of God on Earth" on the basis of Dr. Walther's well-
known theses. Dr. Schick read a German paper on "The Duty of Local
Christian Congregations to Foster Fellowship," a resume of which in the
English language is added. - The District adopted rules and regulations
governing the activities of its Board for Missions and a policy of the
Home Mission Department as to the care of existing stations, missionary
expansion, mission-stations and their financial obligations, and mission-
work in the self-supporting congregations, 8.1so a policy of the Mission
Board in regard to Christian day-schools. These rules may be of
interest to mission boards ,of other Districts. The convention also adopted
regulations concerning the Historical Committee, which was created
some years ago and whose object is to "collect and carefully preserve
the official Proceedings of the Southern lllinois District conventions,
histories of congregations, and other records and materials pertaining
to the history of the District" (p. 68) . Every District ought to have
a committee of this nature, and, if at all possible, a copy of these
records, etc., ought to be sent to our Concordia Historical Institute at
St. Louis. TH. LAETscH
Proceedings of the Southern Nebraska District, 1940. 80 pages, 5%X8%;.
Published as the October, 1940, issue of the Southern Nebraska
District Messenger. Mr. K. G. Ehlers, Garland, Nebr., circulation
manager.
The key-note of the convention of the Southern Nebraska District
was stewardship, and therefore the report deals chiefly with this
important phase of Christian life. Pastor W. Koenig spoke on the
320 Boek Review - ~tterQtur
principles .of Christian stewardship, bringing .out the background, the
meaning, seme· specific implicatiens, and the metive fer, and glery .of,
Christian stewardship. Paster August Ficken carried .out the theught
that Christian stewardship invelves the practice .of bretherly admenitien
in a bretherly spirit, the recegnitien .of its impertance, sincere prayer
te God fer true guidance, and a realizatien that this werk .of leve will
be rewarded. Paster W. Wilkens shewed the relatienship that exists
between stewardship and personal missien-werk. All three essays are
timely and werth-while efferts.
We nete that the Seuthern Nebraska District, in .order te expedite
the electien .of .officers, has adepted the fellewing reselutiens: "In the
afterneen sessien .of the first day Syned shall, by primary ballet, elect
suitable candidates fer the .office .of District President. The six highest
neminees shall be candidates. Syned shall then, by printed ballet,
preceed te the electien .of a District President frem ameng these candi-
dates. . .. All ether .officers and standing cemmittees .of the District,
exclusive .of Visiters, shall be elected in the fellewing manner: Syned
shall, in the afterneen sessien .of the first day, by ballet, neminate a
'Cemmittee en Neminatiens,' censisting .of three pasters, .one teacher,
and three lay delegates . . . .of Syned." TH. LAETSCH
Proceedings of the Forty-First Convention of the Ontario District.
Publishers, Pastors W. o. Rathke and M. C. Weissbach. 55 pages,
6X8.
Our brethren in Canada are carrying en their werk .of spreading
the kingdem of the Prince of Peace while their ceuntry is engaged in
war and many .of their sens are serving in the Army .or Navy. Let us
remember .our brethren in .our prayers, and may Ged held His pretecting
hand ever His Church and its faithful werkers! The address .of Presi-
dent F. Malinsky is particularly timely and teaches lessens needed not
.only in Canada but in .our ceuntry as well. Dr. J. Theedere Mueller .of
our Seminary at St. Louis read an instructive essay en "Stones Crying
Out against Unbelief," emphasizing the importance .of archeelegy fer
our Christian faith and cenfessien. Ta LAETSCH
Proceedings of the Eighteenth Convention of the South Wisconsin
District. Cencordia Publishing Heuse, St. Louis, Me. 52 pages.
Price, 11 cts.
Besides the reutine business .of the District, this report centains
the first twe theses .of Pastor Thee. Gehlke's essay en ''The Relatien .of
Sanctificatien te Justification and Its Implicatiens." Other theses pre-
sented were these en the nature .of justificatien and sanctificatien.
TH.LAETsCB
BOOKS RECEIVED
From Fleming H. Revell Co., New York, London, and Edinburgh:
The Minister's Annual. Velume XIII. Cempiled and edited by
Jeseph McCray Ramsey. 576 pages, 5l,2 X 8l,2. Price, $2.00.
From the United Lutheran Publication House, Philadelphia:
He Started from Nowhere, and Other Stories. By W. R. Siegart.
189 pages, 5l,2x8. Price, $1.00.