- - Spring, 1969 TIXE SPF,INGFIELI)EIZ is published quarterly by the faculty of Con- cordia 'l'heological Seminary, Springfield, Illinois, of the Lutheran Church - Yf issouri Synod. EDITORIiII.. C~O~%Ih.IIT?'EE, Ei:rr.:~r 1-1. I ~ E I N ' ~ z ~ ' : N , Editor R , i ~ n ~ o ~ r t F. SURBCRG, Book Rez7inl? Editor I>,i\v~r.) P . SCAER, Asmcinte Editor ~ I A K I ~ j. S,-~EEGE, Associate Editor I'I:ESII)ENT J. il. 0. PHEUS, ex officio . . Contents PAGE RESPONSES 'r(J "PVHA7' (IOh~lA4l'I'&lFINT TO Tt IE 'S012L4 GKATIA' IN 'THE L,L'l'HERAN C'ONF'ESSLONS 1s-01 dVI;',St' - .- Hrc:~r:i~ru 1. S c ~ c r . 7 - z . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 E r i r c ~ 1-1 .- 1-IEIXTZES . . . . . . . . 7 RF:SPOX\ES TO "TI--IE 1)OC'TI'INE OF ' T I H CHUKCH IN 'I'fl F, IAL7THEKAN CONFESSIONS'! . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (OFIN F. J O H N S O N . . 28 JA.X.II:S ~ C " Z : I S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31 lndcxed irL I N D E X TO I~ELIGIOUS PERIODICAL ITERATURE, published by the Amcrica?~ Tltcologicul Library Aswciation, Lilc.Cornzick Senlinar? Lif)r .ai~ , Clzicugo, : 'li?~ois. Clergy chdngcs of .~ddress reported to Concordia Publishing House, St. Louis, Missouri, will also cover mailing change of Tlze SyiSngficlder. Othcr changes of address should be scnt to the Business Manager of The Spr i~gf ie lder , Con- cordia Theological Seminary, Springfield, Illinois 62702. Address communications to the Editor, Erich H. Heintzen, Concordia Theo logical Seminary, Springfield, Illinois 62702. Commentary on "The Doctrine of The Church in The Lutheran Confessions" T HE INTIMATE RELATION S H I P between the doctrine of the Church and the formulation of the Lutheran Confessions has sonletimes been slighted, if not almost completely overlooked. Great Confessions were distilled from the theological and ecclesiastical ferment so characteristic of the early centuries of the Church's his- torical existcncc. Thc Lutheran Symbols wcrc also occasioned by heretical dogma and anti-Scriptural practice. The Confessions re- sulted from st3rious and ofttimes agoili/ing attempts to cleanse the existing church of error and to proclaim the Gospel of rcdcmptivt. grace which Christ has coinnlittccl to his cli~lrch. The! nxrc at the saint time documents of reco~~ciliat iol~; as thcy sought thc proper praise of the grace of God they also sought thc unity of the church. The franlers of the essq under consicferation (De 13cclesia) remind us that there was, strictly spcaLing, no ecclesiastically fixed and prescribed doctrine or dogma of thc churcti until thc Lutheran Symbols came into existence. Over against various Roman and nledi- eval views, the Symbols asserted the t rue nature of the church while pointing out what is necessary and essential for the true unity of the church. Lutherans are by choice and definition bound to the Scriptures and the Confessions. The Scriptures (norma normans) because they are, in the words of the Confessions, the clear fount of Israel, "the word of God which alone should be and remain the only standard and rule of doctrine, to which the writings of no man should be regarded as equal, but to which everything should be subjected." (F.D., Th . D., C.S., 9). The Confessions, (normn normata) "110t because they were composed by our theologians but because they have been taken from God's MJorcl and founded firmly and well therein." (5.10) The Lutheran Confessions ~lnderstand themselves to be a clear and adequate exposition of Scripture, the summary of Scrip- ture whose heart they recognize to be the Gospel. "The Confessions are introduced as a witness of the truth.'' (13.4) Lutherans look not only to the Scriptures, then, but also to the Confessions to provide a definition of the church as well as adequate determination of the pressing questions relating to church fellowship. The essay on "The Doctrine of the Church" adcpted by the commissioners of The American Lutheran Church and The Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod, sets forth t he following: ' Of The Chzirch 2 9 1. The church is the congregation and assen~bly of all believers in Jesus Christ. "This church actually exists, made up of true be- lievers and righteous men scattered through the world." Its marks are the pure teaching of the Gospel and the Sacraments. (Apology VII and VIII, 20) Faith in Christ is unquestionably constitutive of the church. 2. In order to create and preserve faith thc ministry has been ordained by God. This is a ministry of Word and Sacrament. The church believes the Gospel; and the Gospel is defined, strictly speak- ing, as precisely "a confronting and joyful message ~vhich does not reprove or terrify but comforts consciences, directs them solely to the merit of Christ, and raises them up again by the delightful proc- lamation of God's grace and favor acquired through the merits of Christ." (F.C.,Ep.V., 6-7) The preaching of this Gospel creates, preserves, and sustains Christ's church. (Cf. A.C. ,V ) 3. Within the church are the churches. Those who "preside over the churches" arc to preach the Gospel, remit sins, and admin- ister the Sacraments. (On the I'ou:er nlzd Prinzacy of tlte Pope, 60) . iYhen the bishops refuse ordination "the churchcs retain the right to ordain for themselves." (Ibid., 66-67). The churches, our Con- fessions make explicitly clear, are the Christian community in which we obtain full forgivciless of sins through the Word and the Sacra- lnen ts. 4. The principle of unity anlong the churches is lucidly stated. It is "that the Gospel be preached in confornlity with pure undcr- standing of it." (A.C. VII). \Vhile ceremonies need not be uniform, the Gospel inust be proclaimed in the churchcs. And the Gospel is a divine doctrine, understood in an active and dynanlic sense of public preaching and teaching. True unity among the churches is destroyed by anything which vitiates the Gospel. 5. The Gospel is defined within the context of the Augsburg Confession. The Gospel is the good news of the grace of God in Jesus Christ. The various articles of the At~gusta~la all relate to this Gospel. Article I witnesses to the God of the Gospcl, confessed by the Church as Father, Son, and Spirit. Article 11 renlinds the Church that the Gospel apart from thc I,aw would be pointless. The doctrine of sin must be proclaimed if the Gospel is to be preached properly. (Apology IV, 11, 3 3-34, 50) Article 111 establishes the divine work of atonement, while ArticIe IV defines the very heart of the Gospel: justification by grace proper Christtlm. Similarly all other subjects treated in the Augsburg Confession can be shown to set forth from evangelical perspective the teaching of the church. De Ecclesia emphasizes that a commitment to the pure understanding and preach- ing of the Gospel "calls for fidelity in all matters that are either a part of the Gosl~el or necessary background for the Gospel or a ncces- sary consequence of the Gospel." 6 . Lutherans who seek external unity are to bc guided by these principles. All articles of faith taught in the church are to be tested to determine whether they serve the pure preaching of the Gospel. For any teaching which is contrary to the Gospel impairs the true unity of the church. 7. This stated principle, that true unity among the churches requires that the Gospel be preaching in conformity with a pure understanding of it, is far more than a pious phrase or an ecclesias- tical formula. The Gospel must actually he proclaimed in the pulpits and taught in the churches. This demanded more than a correct statement in an official confession. At the same time it is not to be interpreted as demanding or insisting on an externally pure church. Occasional and incidental aberrations do not destroy the unity of the church; they must, ho~vcver, be dealt with "in a patient and con- ,? structivc manner. 8. $\'hen such a genuine consensus in understanding and tloctrinal conviction has been achieved, Lutheran churches "not only may but shoulcl enter into pulpit and altar fellowship." Churches which recognix- their unitv of faith must alivays submit thcmselvcs to the rcnewing power of ihc Holy Spirit who has promiscd to lead his church into all truth. 9. The churches desiring to establish and preserIc ~ ~ n i t y must carncstly raise thcsc questions, apply thcmsclvcs in love to a cor- rection of errors whcn such arise, and concern themselves with the cleansing of practicc.~ thi~t endangcr thc purity of the Gospel mes- sage. This, in s i ~ m , is the. suhstnncc of thc position sct forth in the cssay, 'l'lle 1)octrine of' the Church in the Lutheran Confessions (De IZcclesin). A careful reading and study leads one, I believe, to say of it what t11c confessors said of their o~vn document: nothing contrary to thc Scriptures. 11. Any scrious tlisc~~ssion of unity among bodies (churches) who ~ ~ o s w s s the Holy Spirit and commit themselves to Christ's holy Gospel leads a C1hristi:~n to considcr thc reality of the church as the Body of Christ ant1 thc pcoplc of God. In and through Jesus Christ God has rc~concilcd an estrangctl ivorltl to himself, breaking down ~valls of partition, cnmity, and scpnration. God in Christ has created a glorious fcllo~vshil> of faith. 'This 1:oinonia is mediated through the \2'ord of rcconcil:~ tion and its concomitant summons to fai th, which is at the same time the call to fc.llowship. ( 1 Cor. 1 : 9) I\'oizzonia with God in Christ lc i~~ls to 1:oitzonin with one ;inother in the Uz-la Snlzcta, as this is so carc~i'uliy dclineatcd in Scripture. (Eph. 4 : lff; 1 John 1 : 3; 1 Cor. 12; Gal. 3: 26ff). Christians are to maintain m ~ d preserveb this unity ant1 fellowship, exercise it in .~vorsllip, (Acts 2 :42 ; I : 14; 4:24f; 8 : 14; 9: 15-19; 15 :36) and extend it by wit- ness and proclamation. (Acts 4 : 20; 1 Cor. 9 : 19f; 2 Cor. 5 : 1 8ff) God's people are also to guard the koinorzia. (Titus 1 : 9-14; 1 Cor. 1 : 1 0 - 1 1 ) by recogniring disunity and by judging 2nd correcting it (Gal. 1 : 6-9; 6: 1-2; 2 John 9-1 1, etc.).