Volume 651 Table of Contents January 2001 Doctrine and Evangelism Alvin L. Barry .................................. 3 Luther and World Missions: A Review Pekka Huhtinen ................................ 15 The Augsburg Confession and its Missiological Significance Karl Hartenstein ............................... 31 Homiletical Studies .................................. 66 The Fifth Sunday after Epiphany, Series C ............................. Carl C. Fickenscher I1 The Second Sunday in Lent, Series C ...... Ken Schurb The Second Sunday of Easter, Series C ............................... Raymond Hartwig The Seventh Sunday of Easter, Series C ................................... David Fleming Theological Observer ................................ 77 Dominus Iesus and Why I Like It ........... David P. Scaer Book Reviews ....................................... 80 What is Mission? Theological Exploration. By J. Andrew Kirk. ....................... Klaus Detlev Schulz Preaching Christ Today: The Gospel and Scientific Thinking. By Thomas F. Tonance ...... Carl C. Fickenscher I1 Ancient-Future Faith: Rethinking Ewangelicalism for a Postmodm World By Robert E. Webber. ................................ John Paul Salay Out of the Saltshaker & into the World. Evangelism as a Way of Life. By Rebecca Manley Pippert. ..................................... Tim Pauls I Evangelism Made Slightly Less Diflicult: How to Interest People Who Aren't Interested By Nick Pollard ................................... Ken Schurb Mission in the Old Testament: Israel as a Light to the Nations. By Walter C. Kaiser Jr. .................................. Chad L. Bird Mission at the Dawn of the-21" Century: A Vision for the Church. Edited by Paul Varo Martinson. ................................ Douglas L. Rutt Beside Still Waters: Searching for Meaning in an Age of Doubt. By Gregg Eastexbrook. Larry M. Vogel ................................ Handbook for William: A Carolingian Woman's Counsel for Her Son. By Dhouda. Translated with an introduction by Carol Neel. Karl F. Fabrizius ............................... Perspectives on War in the Bible. By John A. Wood. Chad L. Bird .................................. Books Received ......................................... 94 The Augsbtlrg Confession and its Missiological Significance Karl Hartenstein' Translated and edited by Klaus Detlev Schulz "I will also speak of your decrees before kings, and shall not be put to shame."' These words from Psalm 119' are written on the title page of the Augsburg Confession. Four hundred years ago, in the chapter-room of the old bishop's palace, a small group of Protestant princes and representatives of free cities read this work before the assembled diet in Augsburg. It was a decisive moment for all of Christianity. Christian Beyer, the chancellor of John the Steadfast, not only read the Augustana - 'The following article is a translation of an essay by Karl Hartenstein, "Die Augsburger Konfession und ihre Bedeutung fiir die Mission," Eva~lgelisclzrs Missio?r~naxazi?i (EMM) [Stuttgart and Basel: Evangelischer Missionsverlag] (December 1930): 353-365. The EMM is now merged in the Zeitschriftfirr Mission. The Base1 Mission Society, for whom Hartenstein served as mission director from 1926-1939, was a dominant and influential mission agency in the modern era of missions. Founded in 1815, it becanlea para-church mission organization for Pietism in Wiirttemberg, the Anglicans in England, the Swiss Reformed and, before the Leipzig mission society ceased its ties with Basel in 1836, also for the Lutherans in Saxony [See: Wilhelni Oehler, Gschiclzte der deutschen trvangelischen Missiorl (Baden-Baden: Wilhelm Fehrholz, 1949), 1: 163-179, 214-2171. Yet it was not unusual for such institutions to have, on occasion, incumbents as directors who were remarkably Lutheran in their approach. The essay by Karl Hartenstein, a Lutheran from Wiirttemberg, is testinlony to this. Together with pivotal figures such as Walter Freytag and Karl Barth, he dominated the European field of missions for many years. Hartenstein's own particular contribution in the pre- and post- World War I1 period was the introduction of the concept of mission as the "history of salvntion" - thereby feeding off the early findings of Oscar Cullmam, a noteworthy professor in Basel who later pubIished his work, Salvatiorr in Histon!. This concept, when coupled with Barth's affirma tion of the "Triu~le God (missio Dei)" in missions and Freytag's esch~tology, contributed substantially towards making missiology a noteworthy theological discipline both at academic institutions and in missionary movements. [See: Biogr~phicd Dictiorrary of Ci~ristian Mission. Edited by Gerald H. Anderson (Grand Rapids: William B. Eerdmans, 1988), 2821. This essay captures basic missiological affirmations from a Lutheran perspective and demonstrates how a confessional document of the Lutheran Church can relate to contemporary contextual issues, which, by and large, have remained pertinent to this very day. 2 The Book of Corz~~ord. The Co~lfessiotis of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. Edited by Robert Kolb and Timothy J. Wengert (Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2000), 31. In further references, this edition will be abbreviated as Book of Concord. 'Psdlrn 119; 46. as this Confession became known - before the cmyesor and empire, but confessed it "with a distinchless of voice and utterance which well accorded with the clearness and firmness of the belief it expressed."' A small group of confessors stood with him, surrounded by the assembled estates of the Holy Roman Empire. Five yri~~ces and two free city representatives dared to confess the scriptural message of the Reformation. They were prepared to sacrifice their lives for Christ, as Wolfgang, the prince of Anhalt, observed in those days: "For pleasure, I often go for a ride with others. Why then should 1 not, when there is a need, also saddle my horse in honor and obedience to my Lord and redeemer Jesus Chnst and, sacrificing my body and life, rush towards the eternal wreath in the heavenly life?"' Here the spirit of the first witnesses bursts forth. M7ith the courage of the apostles and n~artyrs, they boldly confessed. They were determined to obey God ratl~er than men. Luther wrote from the Coburg to Augsburg: "I will not and cannot fear such wretched enemies of God. Their defiance is Iny pride, their rage my cheer. Let the devil tremble, but we will not be afraid. The dear word, the wedding ring, is ours. We will ask for nothing else."6 These are not mere words, but testimonies of people for whom Christ had become more important than anything else in the world. Accordingly, they had to confess the unique, precious, eternally true word before kings and beggars and before the world in which they lived. The Augustana became a priceless gift to millions of Protestant Christians. It thus befits us to reflect seriously upon the words that our fathers, with whom we belong to the one church of Christ, have left us in this Confession. We ask ourselves, what this Confession may tell us as a mission society, which desires to be nothing but a church of God in actu confessionis-a church confessing His word in the world. What does this Protestant Confession have to say to mission? Confession and mission - declaration of faith and proclamation - are inseparable in two ways. Scripture tells us, what confessing Christ means: To follow Christ, to devote ourseIves and sacrifice our service to Him. 4 LeopoId von Ranke, Deutsche Geschichte im Zeitalter der Refonnation (Leipzig Dunker und Humblot, 1873). The quote is taken from its translation: Leopold vor Ranke, History of the Reformation in Germany translated by Sarah Austin (London George Routledge & Sons; New York: E.P. Dutton, 1905), 605. 5 Hans PreuP Luthertum um 1530in Wor! und Bild (Berlin: Furche Kunshierlag, n. d.) 34. 'PreuG, Latiherturn urn 1530,55. ii~lgsbtrrg Confession and its Missiological Significance 33 IJltimateiy, though, everyone's discipleship and all services are tested by one thing. Do we proclaim Him before the world? Do w7e go forth and praise IIim through word and deed as the Savior vf the world? The confessors of Christ have at all times been His lnessengers, witnesses, and missionaries. We can only confess Christ in giving testimony to the kings and beggars of this world and not be ashamed of Him. Mission is testimony. AMission is confession. 'e rise Mission and confession aIso belong together in another sense. \I' the word "confession" also in its other, derived meaning. We thereby mean those words, in which the content of the zestimony has found its expression. We also mean clearly forn~ulated, precisely defined documents that regulate our disciplesf~ip - our personal testimo~ly. Already early on, the church of the confessors laid down coi~fessions to establish claritv in its own practice, to protect itselr from a corruption and dilution of the message and to show the succession of forthcoming generations the right paths and roads. So also the Aidgsburg Co~ifessiox wishes to be nothing but an explanation of that which we can only confess through the deeds in our life. For those whu want to confess Christ through word and life, it is a description of proper discipleship and a beacon for every individual's decisions. Mission, too, has gratefully used such confessions. 'fo be sure, our mission of Base1 is transconfessional. It has never bound itself to a certain Lutheran or Reformed Confession. But it has, for its own instruction and education, alwavs gratefully used the Augustana "as an outstretched arin towards Christ,"'and as a clear guide for messengers and confessors, so that they may, in their preaching of the word and in their life of obedience, give a "clear confession." The national churches as well expect from us a clear confession, succinct words to ward off paganism and all syncretism, to voice in all clarity the truth and conviction of its new world, the church of God, to the old world from which it comes. Therefore, in the history of Basel's mission, the Augustnnn has offered great services in our seminaries and in instruction in all of its fieldsS And 'Leonhard Fendt, Der Willeder Reformation im Auysburgisclzerz h'rk~.nntnis (Tiibingen: J.C.B. Mohr, 1929), 12. &The significance of theconfession for mission is onceagain acu te in the controversy between the German Protestar~t Missionary League (Deutsdzer Eoarrg. Mzssionsbun~~ and the East Asia Mission. This League is a confessional fellowship. Its confession to Christ unites all German speaking missions with one another. It binds ever): missionary to the word of God, protects lum from all missionarv individudlisrn, and so it is, that the ~nissiun demands a clear confession, especially because, on a higher level, mission aspires to be confession, testimony, witness, and discipleship Thus far we can say: to ]lave a confession is to be a missionary, a confessor to the xvorld, l~ke our fathers. This is the first point. To have a confession also ineans to do mission correctly, to testify clearly and truly abut Christ and His work in one's commission, in agreement with the contession of the fathers of the church. This is the second point. Our question theretore is this: How can the Aligzlstana assist us to testdy and confess Christ and Ks word correctly to the world? We shall have it illuminate four aspects for us. The ,-1ligllitrl).lil begins its first article bv witnessing to the living and true God.* It does not spak of a god in general. (For example, it immediately contrasts itself express1~. kvith Islam). It speaks of the one, true God of whom humani~~ 15 ignorant, unIess He reveals Himself to it through His Son. It is the Father of Jesus Cluist, who becomes known here, not just any god, not anv general concept of god. It is the God of Scripture, who reveals Hin~self, not the so-called gods found in thousands of religious documents over all the world. It is the God, who through His Son, entered the world of sin and death and revealed Himself as the Creator, the Redeemer, and the Holy Spirit. By confessing the Triune God at the outset, the L4ugrrstann has avoided everv syncretism. It thereby rejects any claims that the lndiansl" or the Muslims, when they speak of god, imply tl~e God of the Bible. There is no other God than He who is the Lord of the world revealed in Christ. Such is the grand entrance presented in this confession. underscores his position as a \\.itness. 1-hus it was inevitable that the East Asia Mission was rejected for the sake of the confession, clarit)., and truthfulness in affairs. One may see Kirchenblattfur Jir r